Known Issues: Coldcard

SD Card “Airgap”

While better than a USB port, SD cards are not a perfect airgap. Stuxnet proved that the NSA was capable of jumping a USB-drive airgap to harm the Iranian nuclear reactor program.

Small Screen

This makes it hard to manually verify addresses / public key info, and impossible to display QR codes (to minimize using the SD card).

UX Feels More Hacker/Prosumer than Enterprise Grade

The Coldcard Mark3 has come a long way and now features clicky-buttons, a faster processor, and a more RAM (for signing transactions with many inputs).

However, normal users may be skeptical to trust a device to millions of dollars that looks like a child’s calculator. Looks can be deceiving, as this is a very powerful and purpose-built device.

Non-Reproducible Builds

While Coldcard builds are signed by Coldcard, they are not built in a way that is reproducible so they cannot be independently verified. That said, Coldcard firmware is fully open so users can compile it themselves if they want this guarantee.

Fork of Trezor

This hardware wallet was launched by forking some of Trezor’s open-source code. That said, it is very actively maintained and has many new features since then (some that Trezor has not been updated to support).

Written in Python

This is not inherently a problem (python is a good general-purpose programming language!), but several hardware wallets with varying level of multisig support are also written in python, including: Trezor, Coldcard, KeepKey, Specter-DIY, and Passport. These hardware wallets share a lot of upstream code, and it’s possible that if a vulnerability were discovered in one it would be present in the others.

Don’t Be Discouraged

Security is not a binary, and no device is 100% secure. Remember that multisig security is additive, and using this device as part of a proper multisig setup can substantially improve your bitcoin security.